Hands photographing a crushed shipping box containing an alternator for a damage claim

Your Package Is Lost or Damaged, and the Claim Goes Nowhere

November 11, 2026 0 By Andy

Your package is lost. Or it shows up damaged. Or the box is empty. You file a claim. Then nothing happens.

The store tells you to call the shipping firm. The shipping firm tells you to call the store. The claim is denied. The case is closed. You paid for the part, you paid for shipping, and you end up with nothing.

This is a different problem from slow shipping. Slow shipping is about a late box. This one is about the claim runaround when a package is lost or damaged.

Here is how to get through it.

What shipping insurance really covers

Shipping insurance does not cover everything. It often covers loss and damage in transit, but only if you can prove it.

A common trap is the outer box. One buyer had a $250 alternator claim denied because the outer box was not damaged. The part inside was damaged, but the claim was still denied.

Another buyer got an empty box. The insurer did nothing. A third buyer filed a claim, and the company closed the case with no fix.

Read the fine print before you buy insurance, or before you rely on the free coverage that comes with shipping. Check:

  • What counts as damage, and what does not
  • How many days you have to file
  • What proof you need to send
  • Who you file with, the store or the carrier

How to photo the box before you open it

Photos are your best proof. Take them before you open the box.

Photo these things:

  • All six sides of the box
  • Any dents, tears, wet spots, or crushed corners
  • The shipping label and tracking number
  • The tape and seals, and if they look cut or re-taped

Then open the box and photo what is inside. Photo the part, the packing, and any empty space. If the box is empty, photo the empty box with the label in the shot.

Do not throw away the box or the packing. Keep it until the claim is done. The carrier may ask to see it.

Who to contact first and what to save

File the claim as soon as you see the problem. Do not wait a week.

Start with the store you bought from. That is who took your money. Ask in writing:

  • Who handles the claim, the store or the carrier?
  • What is the claim number?
  • What proof do you need to send?
  • What is the deadline?

Save every email, chat log, and photo. Save the order number, the tracking number, and the claim number in one place.

If the store tells you to call the carrier, ask for that in writing too. Then call the carrier and give them the same proof.

What to do when both sides point at each other

This is the most common trap. The store says it is the carrier’s fault. The carrier says it is the store’s fault. No one takes the claim.

Try this:

  1. Write to both sides with the same photos and tracking number
  2. Ask each side to state in writing why the claim was denied
  3. If one side closes the case, write again and ask for a manager or a case review
  4. Keep a log with dates, names, and what each side said
  5. If you paid by card, ask your card company what proof they need for a dispute, and what the deadline is

Do not send the damaged part back until you are told to in writing. You may need it as proof.

A lost or damaged package is bad enough. A claim that goes nowhere makes it worse. Photo the box first, file fast, and keep every piece of proof in one place.